Bitcoin’s price trajectory over the past year has sparked intense debate among investors and analysts following its fourth halving event on April 19, 2024. With the cryptocurrency recently trading at $94,263 after hitting an all-time high above $100,000 late last year, many are questioning whether the halving was truly the catalyst for Bitcoin’s dramatic price increase.
Understanding Bitcoin Halving
Bitcoin’s halving mechanism, which occurs approximately every four years, is built into the cryptocurrency’s code as a way to control inflation and maintain scarcity. During a halving event, rewards for miners who validate transactions on the Bitcoin blockchain are cut in half, effectively reducing the rate at which new Bitcoins enter circulation.
The April 2024 halving was Bitcoin’s fourth such event, reducing the mining reward from 6.25 to 3.125 Bitcoins per block. While previous halvings in 2012, 2016, and 2020 were eventually followed by significant price increases, the immediate impact of the 2024 halving showed a different pattern.
Also Read: Bitcoin Becomes Fifth Largest Global Asset, Surpasses Google’s Market Cap
Initial Sluggish Response
Data compiled by financial analyst David Jagielski indicates that Bitcoin’s price movement in the months immediately following the halving was underwhelming and inconsistent. The cryptocurrency started at $64,994 the day after the halving and showed only modest gains in the subsequent months:
- By May 20, 2024: $71,448 (10% increase)
- By June 20, 2024: $64,829 (essentially flat from halving levels)
- By July 20, 2024: $67,164 (just 3% above halving price)
Even more concerning for halving enthusiasts, Bitcoin actually declined in value during the late summer months:
- By August 20, 2024: $59,013 (9% below halving price)
- By September 20, 2024: $63,193 (3% below halving price)
This lackluster performance challenged the narrative that halvings automatically trigger immediate bull runs, suggesting that other factors might play more significant roles in Bitcoin’s price action.
The Trump Effect
Bitcoin’s fortunes dramatically reversed beginning in November 2024, with the cryptocurrency surging 45% above its halving price by November 20, reaching $94,339. By December 20, it had climbed to $97,756, marking a 50% increase from post-halving levels.
Market analysts widely attribute this sudden acceleration to the U.S. presidential election results rather than delayed effects of the halving. Donald Trump, who campaigned on crypto-friendly policies, secured his second term in November 2024, sparking optimism throughout cryptocurrency markets.
“The real catalyst behind the digital currency’s surge in value was due to something that wasn’t priced in — the election win of a president who was looking at loosening restrictions in the crypto world, and even setting up a bitcoin reserve,” noted Jagielski in his analysis.
Why Halvings May Not Be Reliable Price Catalysts
Financial experts emphasize that while halvings theoretically reduce supply growth, their impact may already be incorporated into Bitcoin’s price before they occur. The 2024 halving was a scheduled, anticipated event that sophisticated market participants had years to prepare for.
“As usual, the 2024 Bitcoin halving event was planned and would have been priced into the digital currency’s valuation even before it happened,” Jagielski explained. “The scarcity was not new or unexpected, so investors shouldn’t have expected it to have an immediate impact on Bitcoin’s valuation, regardless of what may have happened in previous years.“
This phenomenon illustrates the efficient market hypothesis in action—widely anticipated events tend to have minimal impact on asset prices when they actually occur because forward-looking investors have already adjusted their positions accordingly.
Recent Market Behavior Challenges “Digital Gold” Narrative
While Bitcoin proponents have long promoted the cryptocurrency as “digital gold” that serves as a safe haven during economic uncertainty, its recent performance has challenged this characterization. Bitcoin has declined alongside the S&P 500 during market turbulence in early 2025, while traditional gold prices have reached record levels.
“Bitcoin’s proving to be as volatile as ever; it’s a safe investment only when compared to other cryptocurrencies,” observed Jagielski, highlighting that Bitcoin still behaves more like a risk asset than a store of value during market stress.
Although Bitcoin has shown some recovery in recent days, its continued correlation with traditional risk assets suggests that claims of it functioning as “digital gold” remain premature despite its decade-plus existence in financial markets.
What’s Next for Bitcoin?
As Bitcoin trades near $94,000 today, approximately 45% higher than its pre-halving levels, investors remain divided on its future prospects. Bullish observers point to increasing institutional adoption and potential favorable regulatory treatment under the Trump administration as factors that could push Bitcoin to new heights.
However, more cautious analysts emphasize that Bitcoin remains a highly speculative investment subject to extreme volatility. “Bitcoin has hit record highs in recent months, but that doesn’t mean it’s destined to continue going up in value,” warned Jagielski. “Favorable policies from President Trump may lead to greater use and acceptance of the digital currency, but there’s no way of knowing.”
With economic uncertainties persisting globally, investors are advised to approach Bitcoin with appropriate risk management strategies. Financial advisors generally recommend limiting cryptocurrency exposure to a small percentage of diversified portfolios, particularly for those with lower risk tolerance.
“Unless you have a high risk tolerance, you’re likely better off pursuing growth stocks than taking a chance on Bitcoin or any other cryptocurrency,” suggested Jagielski. “With the markets still on shaky ground, speculative investments could be particularly vulnerable to sharp and sudden sell-offs this year.”
As Bitcoin approaches the one-year anniversary of its fourth halving, the evidence suggests that while the event may have contributed to positive long-term sentiment, immediate price action was driven more significantly by external factors—particularly political developments—than by the halving mechanism itself.
Want real-time updates on Bitcoin, Ethereum, and blockchain trends? Crypto News Today delivers breaking crypto news, expert insights, and price movements to keep you informed.
